Bumkins Disposable Cloth Fabric Diaper Liner, Biodegradable, Neutral, 100 Count (Pack of 1)

A little background info:Solely breastfed poop was great because I didn't have to worry about dumping or swirling or spraying anything into the toilet. But ever since we introduced solids into our now two year old daughter's diet, I've been struggling with finding the easiest way to dispose of the poop in her cloth diapers. For awhile she was only going in the morning right after she woke up, so I would use a disposable diaper pad or a disposable diaper when she went to bed. Let me just say, disposable diapers don't contain messes as well as cloth in my experience. At least Seventh Generation diapers don't contain messy loads so well. But hey, I wasn't having to stick my hand in the toilet and tote a dripping dirty diaper cover across the house, so it was what worked for us. And she was only pooping in the morning immediately after waking. BUT- then she starting pooping 2-3, sometimes 4 times a day. And since her recently developed banana obsession, her poop is stickier and more textured than it used to be. So I just started throwing the dirty diapers in the pail without shaking/swirling/spraying- and let me tell you, washing those diapers proved to be quite a pain. Then after finally feeling I'd reached my limit, instead of buying another box of seventh generation diapers to catch her first poop of the day, I decided to give using liners a try.My thoughts on giving these liners a try:And I am so glad I did! It's so easy to dump the poop in the toilet now, AND they help with her sensitive skin. These liners aren't quite as long as the diapers but they are long enough. And they are wide enough that they tuck under the cloth inserts on either side. I wouldn't mind if they were wider so that I could get them to wrap a little more snug around the inserts, but they work plenty good enough as is!

I ordered both the Bumkins liners and the Bummis Bio-Soft in order to compare the two and see which I preferred.The differences I noticed most about the Bumkins were:Larger (can actually split each sheet into 2 if you have the patience to do that, making the box last twice as long)Noticeably softerPop-up style, like a tissue box, seems easier for one-handed use than the Bummis tear-off sheets. In practice, however, I found that it made little difference, because I still needed 2 hands to get the liner properly folded and positioned on the diaper! For this reason, I generally find it easiest to get the liner out and position it in the new diaper before I take the old diaper off of the baby.Bummis pros:Smaller footprint on the changing space (a consideration for us because we have limited space there)Also large enough to possibly split into 2 liners per sheet for a smaller baby, but not for a larger oneBoth brands seem to flush equally well, and both do an excellent job of staying in place. I cloth diapered without liners for my previous baby and with this baby until he started solids, but I definitely prefer the ease the flushable liners add and wouldn't go back to not using them at this point unless we had a septic system that couldn't handle the flushable liners. I do recommend letting the soiled liners sit in the toilet for a couple of minutes or more before flushing -- it supposedly helps them break down more easily and reduce the likelihood of clogging the toilet, though in practice I've never had either brand's usage result in a toilet clog.All in all, I do slightly prefer the softer feel of the Bumkins, but the differences are minor, and I like the smaller footprint for the Bummis. For personal preference the Bumkins win out by a hair, but both brands are similar enough that I wouldn't hesitate to buy either.

This kind of product makes cloth diapering so much easier!! After reading many product reviews, I picked this brand because the consensus seemed to be that they were fairly soft. I've never tried any of the other brands, so I can't say for sure but this has served us well. We've been using them since she was about six weeks old and she is now eighteen months. They usually catch most of the poop (if we place it right, it takes some practice) and they seem soft enough that she doesn't have any issue wearing them in her diaper all the time. There are a couple things to note however.1) Diaper liners are going to be essentially useless until the baby gets most of their nutrition from solid food. Otherwise the poop is just too soft for it to catch it. We still used them at that point because we felt sometimes the liner stopped the poop from staining the diaper as much, but it could also contribute to leaks.2) I thought these were going to be packaged like tissues, where you grab one out of the box. Instead they're wadded up and together in such a way that it is a pain to get one out and one handed. Because of this issue we always prepare the diaper (lay out cover, then prefold, then liner) before we chase down the kid. Much easier that way.